Rabbi Chanina, an assistant of the high priest said: Pray for the welfare of the government, since but for fear of it men would swallow each other alive. (m.Avot 3:2)
In the Hebrew Roots movement there is often a strong anti-government sentiment woven into the core belief system, and government conspiracy theories abound. While some of this paranoia is justified (we should never be completely ignorant of the inevitable manipulations of governing authorities), the far majority of it is merely based on fear and an aversion of authority. These are the same people that are anti-rabbinic and fabricate all kinds of misinformation about the Talmud and rabbinic writings. Organized religion of any sort can’t be trusted. In their minds a ruling authority of any kind is illegitimate and power-hungry. However, we must realize that governing systems are necessary for the welfare of humanity.
Of the seven categories of commandments that are incumbent upon all of humanity by way of what has been codified as the Noachide Laws, establishing a system of courts and a legal system to uphold civil law is one of them. Why? Because without it, as our mishnah says, “men would swallow each other alive.” Irving Bunim, in his commentary on this passage, points out that humans can be inherently cannibalistic. It is human nature to devour other humans by any means possible. We will find a way to dominate, subjugate, and denigrate another human being at the drop of a hat. However, Hashem requires us to resist our base nature and assist those who have no assistance, to protect those who have no protection, and to defend those who have no defense. Therefore, a system of justice is required in order to protect the weak and the innocent from the indomitable and culpable.